House 2008: Open Seat Watch (October)

Another month, another opportunity to round up all the retirements and open seats that may pop up in next year’s House elections. We have a few changes since our last installment in September, with the retirements of Republicans Jerry Weller (IL-11) and Terry Everett (AL-02), and the decision of GOP Rep. Heather Wilson (NM-01) to run for the Senate. IL-11 and NM-01 stand to be top-tier pick up opportunities for Democrats, and Democrats are hoping that a strong candidate emerges to give Republicans a run for their money in the Alabama seat. (Paging Bobby Bright?) One development that may lift NRCC spirits is the possibility that Jim Ramstad (MN-03) will un-retire, putting a toss-up district into much safer territory for Republicans. For now, we’ll keep him on The List, with the appropriate question mark.

Following the format of the previous diaries, I’ve put together two charts: one tracking definite retirements and the other potential retirements, resignations, and primary defeats, listing each district by its incumbent, PVI, and the representative’s age on election day in 2008.

Definite House Retirements







District Incumbent Party PVI Age Notes
AL-02 Everett R R+13.2 71 Will retire
AZ-01 Renzi R R+2.2 50 Will resign
CA-52 Hunter R R+9.3 60 Running for President
CO-02 Udall D D+8.1 58 Running for Senate
IL-11 Weller R R+1.1 51 Retiring
IL-14 Hastert R R+4.8 67 Retiring
IL-18 LaHood R R+5.5 62 Retiring
ME-01 Allen D D+6.2 63 Running for Senate
MN-03 Ramstad R R+0.5 62 Retiring (?)
MS-03 Pickering R R+14.1 45 Retiring
NM-01 Wilson R D+2.4 47 Running for Senate
OH-15 Pryce R R+1.1 57 Retiring

That adds up to 10 House retirements for Republicans, many of them in marginal districts. As the retirement trends from the 2005/2006 cycle suggest, there still is plenty of time for more House members to grab a life preserver and bail.

Potential House Retirements






































































































































































































District Incumbent Party PVI Age Notes
AK-AL Young R R+14.3 75 Under investigation
CA-04 Doolittle R R+10.9 58 Under investigation
CA-24 Gallegly R R+4.8 64 Botched a retirement attempt in 2006
CA-25 McKeon R R+7.1 70 Speculation
CA-41 Lewis R R+9.0 74 Under investigation
CO-05 Lamborn R R+15.7 54 Primary challenge
CO-06 Tancredo R R+10 62 Undecided
CT-04 Shays R D+5.4 63 Threatening retirement
DE-AL Castle R D+6.5 69 Health issues
FL-10 Young R D+1.1 78 Age issues/Speculation
IL-03 Lipinski D D+10.3 42 Primary challenge
IA-03 Boswell D D+1.4 74 Health issues
IA-04 Latham R D+0.4 60 Possible Senate run
IA-05 King R R+8.4 59 Possible Senate run
IN-07 Carson D D+8.7 70 Health issues
LA-01 Jindal R R+18.5 37 Running for Governor
LA-02 Jefferson D D+27.8 61 Indicted
MD-01 Gilchrest R R+9.8 62 Primary challenge
MD-04 Wynn D D+29.8 57 Primary challenge
MD-06 Bartlett R R+12.8 82 Age issues
MI-03 Ehlers R R+9.0 74 Speculation
NC-09 Myrick R R+12.2 67 Speculation
NJ-03 Saxton R D+3.3 60 Speculation
NY-23 McHugh R R+0.2 60 Speculation
OH-02 Schmidt R R+13.1 56 Primary challenge
OH-07 Hobson R R+6.0 72 Rumors
OH-16 Regula R R+3.6 84 Age issues/Speculation
TN-09 Cohen D D+18.1 59 Primary challenge
TX-04 Hall R R+17.1 85 Age issues
VA-11 Davis R R+0.6 59 Possible Senate run
WY-AL Cubin R R+19.4 61 Speculation

Deletions from this list include Don Manzullo (IL-16), who filed to run again, and Jo Ann Davis (VA-01), who passed away from an ongoing battle with cancer on the weekend. I’ve added Tancredo and Lamborn in Colorado — both have questionable futures in the House. Another addition is Julia Carson, who returns to the list after being scratched last month. While she did announce her re-election, her poor health is increasingly becoming a major story in national and local media, and her fundraising has been beyond anemic. Unfortunately, I have little choice but to add her back to the watch list.

Babs Cubin is also staying on the list, despite saying recently that she “absolutely intends” to run again “at this point in time”. Uh-huh. “At this point in time” and “intend” in the same sentence is a huge retirement red flag. The same goes for New York Republican Jim McHugh, who put it a bit more strongly, but still left the door open for a vacancy by saying “at this time, I fully expect to be a candidate for re-election in 2008”. Expectations have a funny habit of changing, and so does the mind of a congressman. He stays on the watch list.

Anyone else we should know about? Let us know in the comments.

7 thoughts on “House 2008: Open Seat Watch (October)”

  1. Here is an article about possible Republican primary challenges:

    http://news.yahoo.co

    The 11 seats mentioned (some of which you list above) are:

    CA-04 Doolittle
    CO-05 Lamborn
    FL-08 Keller
    GA-10 Broun
    IN-05 Burton
    MD-01 Gilchrest
    NC-03 Jones
    OH-02 Schmidt
    TX-04 Hall
    TX-14 Paul
    UT-03 Cannon

    Some of these primaries are based on speculated, rather than announced challengers, so they may not qualify for your list.

  2. Thanks, James, for the excellent charts.  Postings like this are a valuable resource for me.  I want to suggest that you enhance you’re blue and red PVI numbers by making the incumbent’s Party listing red or blue too.  The reason for my suggestion is that the color combinations of the two columns can make for a VERY quick reference when looking for information in a hurry.  Just a suggestion.  Thanks again.

  3. Dr. Steve Kagen won the 8th COngressional Dist in NE Wisconsin with 141,570 votes over his opponent, the GOp Assmbly Speaker Joh Gardm with 135,622.

    The Wisconsin GOP is trying to spin this win by using only one of the 16 counties this, the 2nd largest district in the state. The GOP’s are using Brown County’s close result. A 859 vote difference. Neither candidate lives in Brown COunty. duh?

    Kagen lives in OUtagamie ( Appleton).. and won with over 6,000 votes.
    Gard lives in Marinette County and he won by 512, out of 16,955 cast.
    Kagen took Green Bay by 859 votes.

    Kagen took the entire 8th with an almost 6,000 vote lead.

    Wisconsin has not had a GOP Senator since 1957, when Joe McCarthy died and the last time we elected a Republican President was in 1984

    Gard is planning on a re-run. His record in Madison was dismal and onstructionist, and with the state not having a budget, from Gard’s leftover obstructionist buddies…well, his sstyle of legislating is questionable.
      Bush even flew in on Air FOrce One Twice, and Cheney showed up once and they had a expensive golfing outing at Whislting Sands in Kohler, with Rudy…who dropped out at the last minute.

    So it can stay Dem as long as we get some support here.

Comments are closed.